As promised, I want to return to the topic of the TT/ST Ratio: the Teacher Talk to Student Talk Ratio. You might want to browse last week's post, part 1, to catch up to where we are.
It is my premise that, withing the bounds of reason, more student talk is better than some or none. Here's why:
The students are engaged! If the students are quiet, they are often passive. Maybe they are listening, but maybe they are not. If they are making noise---answering or asking questions, talking with each other (in teacher directed activity), or even the chaotic murmur that characterizes craft activity---they are at least on task.
Sometimes, teacher talk in the form of lecture is necessary. (Don't kid yourself, you could be lecturing to preschoolers and preteens, as well as college students and adults, if the teacher is doing all the talking.) But lecture has a huge drawback from an educational standpoint. You don't know what the students are really picking up. They may be confused, but afraid or not permitted to ask questions. They may have mentally checked out and "gone home," even though 30 minutes of class time remain. They may be distracted by a classmate, a poster on the wall, or a bird in the bush outside the window. If they are silent, you don't know where they are in the learning process. Well, okay, you could give quizzes or require that they fill in blanks on a hand-out as you lecture, but really, I know we can do better. Lecture shows how much the teacher knows, but it shows nothing about what the student knows.
Catechesis is a great tool! Asking questions and drawing the students into giving answers or asking questions of their own is a much more effective way of hearing what the students are learning in class. The more great questions you ask the lower your TT/ST Ratio. That's a good thing.
Student reports are good. This can be a two-edged sword. The time students invest in preparing reports, unless they are given as homework, will show on your class sound audit as silence or, if you have asked for teamwork in the reports, discussion or chaos. So, keep the report assignments narrow in scope and easy to accomplish in just a few minutes. Then couple the student talk/reporting time with discussion/asking questions. You will still lower that TT/ST Ratio.
How do YOU know whether your students are engaged in your lesson?
What are other ways to reduce the Teacher Talk to Student Talk Ratio?
Thanks for teaching God's children His Word!
Search This Blog
Monday, July 18, 2011
Monday, July 11, 2011
What Do You Hear? Part 1
Imagine that you recorded one of the recent Bible lessons you taught. You pressed "Record" when the first student arrived and "Stop" when the last one went out the door. Now, play that tape back in your mind. What do you hear?
Do you hear mostly your own voice? Giving instructions. Reading from the Bible. Asking questions. Leading the students in prayer. Do you hear mostly voices of the students? Answering questions or asking questions of their own. Reading. Singing. Praying. Talking to each other. Do you hear silence? Do you hear chaos?
What should you hear? How would an excellent lesson sound? Many years ago, Rev. Locke E. Bowman, Jr., a gifted Christian educator and president of the National Teacher Education Project, taught me to be aware of the Teacher Talk to Student Talk Ratio.
It's a simple calculation. Divide the amount of time during which the teacher talks by the amount of time students are talking. If the teacher talks for 45 minutes and the students talk for 15 minutes the TT/ST ratio is 3. If the amounts are equal, the ratio is 1.
What does the TT/ST ratio in your lessons tell you? Would you rather it be high, more teacher than student? Low? Why?
I invite you to ponder this one for a few days! I promise to return to this topic next week with some further thoughts of my own.
Do you hear mostly your own voice? Giving instructions. Reading from the Bible. Asking questions. Leading the students in prayer. Do you hear mostly voices of the students? Answering questions or asking questions of their own. Reading. Singing. Praying. Talking to each other. Do you hear silence? Do you hear chaos?
What should you hear? How would an excellent lesson sound? Many years ago, Rev. Locke E. Bowman, Jr., a gifted Christian educator and president of the National Teacher Education Project, taught me to be aware of the Teacher Talk to Student Talk Ratio.
It's a simple calculation. Divide the amount of time during which the teacher talks by the amount of time students are talking. If the teacher talks for 45 minutes and the students talk for 15 minutes the TT/ST ratio is 3. If the amounts are equal, the ratio is 1.
What does the TT/ST ratio in your lessons tell you? Would you rather it be high, more teacher than student? Low? Why?
I invite you to ponder this one for a few days! I promise to return to this topic next week with some further thoughts of my own.
Tuesday, July 5, 2011
Summer Sunday School
Summer brings new challenges for Sunday School. Sometimes teachers become scarce. Those who have taught faithfully for nine months take a break. Replacing them is often a struggle. Attendance may sag; families go away on vacation, or just take a vacation from church.
Some congregations pack it in; keeping Sunday School functioning is just too much work, they say. But then they have to start all over again in the fall. Some congregations go the summer entertainment route: puppet shows, magicians, and videos featuring talking vegetables and graceless moralism. But I also know that many congregations press on, continuing to offer their standard Sunday School classes come what may. And I know of many that take the summer as a chance to do something new, site rotation, intergenerational classes, and the like---but with a continued emphasis on Law and Gospel, such theological and pedagogical content.
CPH's Growing in Christ summer material can be taught in a traditional classroom setting, but adapts wonderfully to a site rotation format. The first week of June, my wife and I (well, mostly my wife) taught over 30 first through fifth graders by ourselves and it went fine. (Thankfully, more volunteers have stepped up as summer has progressed.)
How is it going where you serve?
What is your biggest summer challenge?
Some congregations pack it in; keeping Sunday School functioning is just too much work, they say. But then they have to start all over again in the fall. Some congregations go the summer entertainment route: puppet shows, magicians, and videos featuring talking vegetables and graceless moralism. But I also know that many congregations press on, continuing to offer their standard Sunday School classes come what may. And I know of many that take the summer as a chance to do something new, site rotation, intergenerational classes, and the like---but with a continued emphasis on Law and Gospel, such theological and pedagogical content.
CPH's Growing in Christ summer material can be taught in a traditional classroom setting, but adapts wonderfully to a site rotation format. The first week of June, my wife and I (well, mostly my wife) taught over 30 first through fifth graders by ourselves and it went fine. (Thankfully, more volunteers have stepped up as summer has progressed.)
How is it going where you serve?
What is your biggest summer challenge?
Monday, June 27, 2011
Teacher Training Ideas
I've lamented before that training opportunities for Sunday School teachers seem to have gone by the wayside. A few decades ago we saw weekly Sunday School meetings, regular training classes, annual regional conferences, teacher "certification" programs, and a national convention. Now I fear that some congregations manage a quarterly teachers' meeting, but most offer no organized training at all. I know we can do better.
So a recent post by the Sunday School Revolutionary (Darryl Wilson, a Sunday School leader for the Kentucky Baptist Convention) caught my eye. Under the title (you can link to his post by clicking on the title) "Twelve Months of Sunday School Teacher Training," he offers several creative suggestions for equipping teachers, including some that encourage us to spread the leadership roles with others.
send teachers an article or blog post to read and answer three questions to prepare for discussion at the meeting
ask the pastor to share the background of book(s) teachers will be covering in the upcoming quarter
ask one of your teachers (could be in each age group) to be prepared to demonstrate a teaching method for the group--allow time to debrief/dialogue
show a short Sunday School training video--allowing time to debrief/dialogue
read a short section of a Sunday School book to teachers--divide them into groups to dialogue, closing with a summary
devote one of your planning meetings to training beginning with a 20-30 minute presentation and dividing into age groups for application each one facilitated by an age group teacher
Great ideas! Implementing even one or two of them would provide a helpful shot in the arm for those who teach God's children His Word in your congregation.
What do you think? Are my impressions accurate? What is the state of teacher training in your Sunday School?
What training suggestions can you add to Darryl's list?
So a recent post by the Sunday School Revolutionary (Darryl Wilson, a Sunday School leader for the Kentucky Baptist Convention) caught my eye. Under the title (you can link to his post by clicking on the title) "Twelve Months of Sunday School Teacher Training," he offers several creative suggestions for equipping teachers, including some that encourage us to spread the leadership roles with others.
Great ideas! Implementing even one or two of them would provide a helpful shot in the arm for those who teach God's children His Word in your congregation.
What do you think? Are my impressions accurate? What is the state of teacher training in your Sunday School?
What training suggestions can you add to Darryl's list?
Monday, June 20, 2011
The Temple Test
Christian apologetics is on my mind a lot these days. The writings of Ken Ham and Brad Alles urge us to be a bit more deliberate (no, a lot more deliberate) about preparing Sunday School students to face a world that is often hostile to their faith.
How can we make sure that the lessons we teach on Sunday morning will be distinctively Christian and Lutheran?
A wise man who helped me get started in the Sunday School editing business, Rev. Earl Gaulke, spoke occasionally of using the temple test.
It works like this. Just ask yourself: Could the lessons we teach, the materials we use, be taught in a temple of another faith (Jewish, Islam, Baptist, etc.) without causing those who worship and study there to object? If there would be no objections, our lessons have failed the test! They have not adhered to the truth of Scripture that Jesus is "the way, the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through [Him]" (John 14:6 ESV).
We do the children we teach a disservice when the lesson we teach present godless morality, Christless salvation, or religious life absent the Sacraments through which Jesus promises to be with us. That hour of opportunity each week, when God's children gather in your classroom to study His Word, is too precious to waste!
Am I too harsh?
How do you evaluate the material you teach?
How can we make sure that the lessons we teach on Sunday morning will be distinctively Christian and Lutheran?
A wise man who helped me get started in the Sunday School editing business, Rev. Earl Gaulke, spoke occasionally of using the temple test.
It works like this. Just ask yourself: Could the lessons we teach, the materials we use, be taught in a temple of another faith (Jewish, Islam, Baptist, etc.) without causing those who worship and study there to object? If there would be no objections, our lessons have failed the test! They have not adhered to the truth of Scripture that Jesus is "the way, the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through [Him]" (John 14:6 ESV).
We do the children we teach a disservice when the lesson we teach present godless morality, Christless salvation, or religious life absent the Sacraments through which Jesus promises to be with us. That hour of opportunity each week, when God's children gather in your classroom to study His Word, is too precious to waste!
Am I too harsh?
How do you evaluate the material you teach?
Monday, June 13, 2011
What Can We Evaluate?
I'm wrestling this week with the concept of evaluation in Sunday School.
Over the years, I've operated from the conviction that things benefit from inspection. The simple act of looking at something is the beginning of opportunity, while ignoring things guarantees the continuation of the status quo. Okay, there are exceptions, surprises ("silent growth while we are sleeping," in the words of Fred Pratt Green, Hope Publishing 1970), but even those we see only when we get around to looking.
So, what can we look at in Sunday School that will bring blessings for our task of teaching God's children His Word?
Volunteers will generally fear evaluation by others. Most are insecure enough in their role to suspect that in any evaluation they will be judged inferior, not really sufficient for the task. (In fact, most volunteers are proably duing a commendable job, else they would not remain in their positions.) They are likely open though to self-evaluation.
Other aspects of Sunday School will also defy evaluation. Faith is a perrsonal and internal matter that is not subject to our human examination or measurement. Numbers (students registered or attending, and the like) may not be helpful for evaluation; the root causes for changes in numbers may be difficult to discern.
What needs to be included in a Sunday School evaluation?
Over the years, I've operated from the conviction that things benefit from inspection. The simple act of looking at something is the beginning of opportunity, while ignoring things guarantees the continuation of the status quo. Okay, there are exceptions, surprises ("silent growth while we are sleeping," in the words of Fred Pratt Green, Hope Publishing 1970), but even those we see only when we get around to looking.
So, what can we look at in Sunday School that will bring blessings for our task of teaching God's children His Word?
Volunteers will generally fear evaluation by others. Most are insecure enough in their role to suspect that in any evaluation they will be judged inferior, not really sufficient for the task. (In fact, most volunteers are proably duing a commendable job, else they would not remain in their positions.) They are likely open though to self-evaluation.
Other aspects of Sunday School will also defy evaluation. Faith is a perrsonal and internal matter that is not subject to our human examination or measurement. Numbers (students registered or attending, and the like) may not be helpful for evaluation; the root causes for changes in numbers may be difficult to discern.
- So what's left to look at?
Environment (are we providing attractive space, places where children will want to be and where parents will want to bring them?) - Curriculum (are we provide theologically and educationally sound material that above all else shares Christ are Savior?)
- Administration (are effective systems in place to provide volunteers, training, resources, and visibility for the Sunday School?)
What needs to be included in a Sunday School evaluation?
Monday, June 6, 2011
What My School Teacher Says or What the Bible Says?

I had a brief debate yesterday morning with a young man, a first or second grader, who was not buying the Bible's notion of a six-day creation. It was very brief; I didn't intend to engage in any kind of contest and I didn't expect to win if I tried.
Already in his early years of, I assume, public education, this young man had been taught, and was firmly convinced, that the earth was millions of years old, the dinosaurs and man could not have been created at the same time or lived peacefully together on the earth, and the dinosaurs perished millions of years ago because of a "big volcano." (Maybe it was not public education, after all, but children's television and movies.)
That God's Word is true, a reliable source of information about all that it teaches, including a six-day creation, is ultimately a matter of faith. So I made my case, in language that I hoped the others in the mixed-age class could understand. "This is what the Bible says. The Bible also promises forgiveness of sins to all people who, like Adam and Eve, have sinned and turned away from God and then hear again God's Word of salvation through the sacrifice of Jesus."
But I'm praying for that young man, and for all the other children who hear God's Word, that their hearts will be open to hear it. And I hurt for the many ways that tender faith will be challenged as children encounter a world that does not believe what the Bible teaches.
God bless all of you who take time to teach God's children His Word.
How would you have handled this encounter?
At what age should be engage children in "serious theological discussion"?
Already in his early years of, I assume, public education, this young man had been taught, and was firmly convinced, that the earth was millions of years old, the dinosaurs and man could not have been created at the same time or lived peacefully together on the earth, and the dinosaurs perished millions of years ago because of a "big volcano." (Maybe it was not public education, after all, but children's television and movies.)
That God's Word is true, a reliable source of information about all that it teaches, including a six-day creation, is ultimately a matter of faith. So I made my case, in language that I hoped the others in the mixed-age class could understand. "This is what the Bible says. The Bible also promises forgiveness of sins to all people who, like Adam and Eve, have sinned and turned away from God and then hear again God's Word of salvation through the sacrifice of Jesus."
But I'm praying for that young man, and for all the other children who hear God's Word, that their hearts will be open to hear it. And I hurt for the many ways that tender faith will be challenged as children encounter a world that does not believe what the Bible teaches.
God bless all of you who take time to teach God's children His Word.
How would you have handled this encounter?
At what age should be engage children in "serious theological discussion"?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)